How do we know Milky Way is a 'barred' spiral galaxy?

  • In reference to the question, "How can we tell that the milky way is a spiral galaxy?"



    The answers there clearly sum up the question asked. But Milky Way is not just a spiral galaxy. It is further classified as a barred spiral galaxy.



    Question: Which particular feature in the distribution of stars, or in general a feature in observations led us to believe that it is a barred galaxy?



    Note: The edge-on picture is not sufficient to establish it, since a dense distribution at smaller radii could also arise from a non-uniform density on the spiral disk if modeled to fit the observations. We don't have any data from other angles or orientations.


  • Walter

    Walter Correct answer

    9 years ago

    There are several different lines of evidence which together form a coherent picture: that of a barred galaxy. Moreover, as most disc galaxies are barred, we should expect the same from the Milky Way. The various evidences are:



    The observed light distribution (2MASS) shows a left-right asymmetry in brightness and the vertical height. This is explained by the near end of the bar being located on that side.



    The observed gas velocities show velocities which are "forbidden" in an axisymmetric or near-axisymmetric (spiral arms only) galaxy. These velocities occur naturally from the orbits of gas in a barred potential



    The velocity distribution of stars in the Solar neighbourhood shows some asymmetries and clumping which is most naturally explained by orbital resonance with the bar rotation.



    The extent, pattern speed, and orientation of the bar is consistent between all three of these.


    Nice answer! Can you add a few references to articles or instruments concerning at least some of these things you mention: gas velocity measurements, solar neighbourhood assymetries and clumping, bar parameters fitting.

    Can you provide something that backs up the item about velocity clumps in the solar neighbourhood are due to resonance with the bar - genuinely interested.

    @RobJeffries Look at my article and any quoting it.

    Ah that "Walter"! I'll check it out - I am interested in young moving groups and similar kinematic structures.

    @RobJeffries psst about that walter here.

License under CC-BY-SA with attribution


Content dated before 7/24/2021 11:53 AM

Tags used