Could a cross-ringed planet exist?

  • My title doesn't do my question justice in explaining, but the kind of satellite system I'm thinking of is two rings on two separate axis, much like (if you've seen it) the film 'Treasure Planet' shown below.

    enter image description here

    My guess is no, as the ring of a planet matches it's axis, but I was wondering whether or not some other phenomenon or influence could cause this formation.

    It's not stable long term, but for a short while it would be fine.

    If the rings intersect, I wouldn't expect it to last very long at all.

    It's likely it could not even form at all if the rings would intersect.

  • The answer is a bit more complex than what userLTK presents.

    Tides play a huge role for the orientation of the rings.

    If the ring system has an inclination relative towards the planet, then inclination damping will occur.
    This means that the planet, that is flattened due to its own rotation, will exert asymmetric force tugs onto orbiting masses, until the force tugs are symmetric again, which is the case for zero inclination. This works well beyond the Roche-sphere of a planet.

    Think about Uranus ring and moon-system.

    (c) Keck Telescope team (c) Keck Telescope Team

    It seems implausible from a planetary formation viewpoint that Uranus could have an inclined subdisc from which the rings and moons formed at this inclination.

    What seems more likely is that the planet was tilted, and then forced rings and moons to follow.


    Yes on very short timescales, but then the rings would look messier and thicker as they would have to be just freshly formed.

    No on long timescales (~10.000 years based on a quick google search).

License under CC-BY-SA with attribution

Content dated before 7/24/2021 11:53 AM