What's the purpose of having so many subgenres of music?

  • I am quite aware that there are more than a thousand subgenres for music. So what is the use for them? Who needs them and why?

    for the same stupid reason they tell us genres exist. marketing.

  • Cort Ammon

    Cort Ammon Correct answer

    5 years ago

    The sub-genres exist because someone wanted them to exist.

    This is really a specific case of a much more general question of why people put things in categories in the first place. It's a deeply rooted human trait, with applications far beyond just music theory.

    We have genres because we like to be able to capture complex things in a small number of words. When we are told "Hey, you should go listen to band XYZ," actually taking the time to go listen to them can be very, well, time consuming. If we value our time, we want to get some sense of what we're about to get into, so we ask "what genre of music do they play?" We can then file the recommendation to listen to the band alongside that one or two word genre, permitting us to prioritize. I'm not about to waste my time listening to some new orchestral piece when my house is noisy. I'll save that for when the house is quiet and I can appreciate it properly. Likewise, the latest thrash metal is probably not what I should listen to right before my wife and I go off for a romantic dinner.

    The raw number of categories we create is a side effect of this process. Some people feel their music is too "out there" to fit into an existing genre, so they seek to define their own new genre. Other times it works the opposite way: someone wants to call their work as part of a genre, but the music snobs refuse to let them.

    We also see more genres form when people want different types of categorization. To pick a trivial example, if I like music with a fast tempo rather than slow, and you like music with a full orchestra rather than just a few instruments, neither one of our categorizations is complete. We need something more, like "fast orchestral music," and thus a new genre is born.

    Genres live and die constantly. They're fickle things which float on the backs of our own obsessions with categorization. The reason there are so many subgenres of music is because there are so many people out there actively keeping those sub-genres alive.

    An interesting comparason can be made in the movie industry. Netflix famously handed out the "Netflix Prize" to anyone who could use their 5-star ratings as input to help predict what movies to recommend. BellKor, the winning algorithm, identified movies on 50 distinct dimensions. That's not genres... its dimensions. Each "genre" of movie was identified by a string of 50 numbers! Trivially, if there were only two valid values on each dimension, that would qualify as 1,125,899,906,842,624 sub-genres! Woof!

License under CC-BY-SA with attribution

Content dated before 7/24/2021 11:53 AM

Tags used