Will duplicated MAC address give problems, if in different VLANs?

  • A small company has 2 Cisco Catalyst 3550, with 24 ports each, connecting their equipaments.

    After some trouble, we found that two NICs had the same MAC address. After the initial reaction of blaming who bought such NICs, etc., I began to wonder: if the NICs belong to separate VLANs, would it still cause problems?

    Could I connect each NIC to a different VLAN and work ok (except in the future, if someone forget that and connect them to the same VLAN again) ?

    :) In Brazil we call it XingLing, but I just found that actually there is a company with that name, and that internationally it's called Shanzhai

    @woliveirajr, would you mind adding the first three bytes of the duplicate mac-addresses? a googlable record of the OUI may help someone in the future

    those NICs were trashed away, I'll look for logs and will post afterwards...

    For reference, a number of years back there was a bad BIOS image that when used on certain motherboards would corrupt the MAC of the on board Nvidia NICs, leaving them with 044b.8080.8003 or 044b.8080.8004 as the MAC (and no way to fix). Came across this troubleshooting a problem at a university where one of the departments had purchased a number of these for use in a computer lab.

    Those NICs began with 00E04C , but I can assure that they were not RealTek ones... now I'm curious on how is works when you set the MAC address by hand, but I'll ask another question about it (and won't be able to test any further on those NICs)

  • As long as the NICs are in completely different layer-2 broadcast domains, it shouldn't be a problem, but it is a headache waiting to happen when one of them is moved. If there are just two offending NICs, it's probably better to replace one.

License under CC-BY-SA with attribution

Content dated before 7/24/2021 11:53 AM

Tags used